Citizenship: Naturalization Based on 5 year Eligibility

The requirements to become a U.S. citizen by way of an N-400 Application for Naturalization are generally not complicated, although situations frequently arise where significant questions regarding an applicant’s eligibility are raised.

5 year green card

Find Out How We Can Solve Your
Immigration Problem

General Requirements for Naturalization

  1. The applicant must be at least 18 years of age and a lawful permanent resident for 5 years. For those who are married to a U.S. citizen, the requirement is only 3 years or residence, although the applicant must have been married to and living with that U.S. citizen spouse for at least 3 years to qualify for this shortened eligibility period.
  2. The applicant must demonstrate “good moral character” during the qualifying 5 or 3 year period.
  3. The applicant must not have been absent from the U.S. for 1 year or more during any single stay outside the U.S. over the course of the qualifying period AND the applicant must not have been absent from the U.S. an aggregate of more than half of that time. Absences of more than 6 months, but less than a year, during the qualifying period can be problematic, depending on the circumstances.
  4. Applicants must demonstrate the ability to read, write and speak English along with a basic knowledge of U.S. government and history. Certain exceptions are made for various classes of older residents who have been residing in the U.S. for extended periods, as well as for individuals with physical and mental disabilities.

Naturalization Requirements Questions and Answers

Q: Can I submit my application prior to accumulating the requisite period of residence?
A: Yes. Applications can be filed during the 90 day window prior to accumulating the necessary years of residence.

Q: What if I was the subject of criminal charges during or even before the qualifying period?
A: Generally, criminal charges that are dismissed do not pose any eligibility problems, as long as the applicant discloses the fact that they were arrested (it will show up on the fingerprint report anyway, and even if the record gets expunged). Criminal charges that lead to a conviction will definitely affect eligibility, even convictions for driving under the influence and even some convictions taking place prior to the eligibility period. Given the complexity of the law in this area, as well as the potential deportation consequences, I would advise all applicants with criminal backgrounds to consult with experienced immigration counsel before submitting an Application for Naturalization. The same goes for prospective applicants who may be facing other non-criminal bases of ineligibility – such as accidentally voter registration, voting, or other acts – as immigration authorities generally lean toward denying applications where a close call is involved, and even placing applicants in removal proceedings if any legal basis is at play. Moreover, the fact that an applicant’s act may have taken place prior to the 5 year eligibility period does not mean it cannot be held against them and negatively impact the decision making process.

Q: What if I no longer reside with or married to my U.S. citizen spouse petitioner and the basis of my N-400 application is the 5 year eligibility/residence period?
A: While being married to or sharing a residence with your U.S. citizen petitioner is theoretically not required for 5 year naturalization eligibility, N-400 applicants should be mindful of the fact that CIS adjudicators will closely scrutinize the underlying marriage. The timeline for relationship break up and the exact dates the parties shared a residence will be closely examined to determine if that underlying marriage was indeed genuine – and not entered into just to facilitate green card issuance. A negative finding in this regard could lead to application denial and even issuance of a Notice to Appear for removal proceedings.

Q: How will absences of longer than 180 days – but less than a year, affect my eligibility?
A: Applicants with such absences during the qualifying period will have the burden of demonstrating to the CIS adjudicating officer they did not abandon their residence during this period, and therefore the extended departure should not constitute a break in the qualifying residency period. Factors considered by the CIS in assessing the nature of the departure include: did the applicant take work overseas? Did the applicant maintain a place of residence, bank account, business affiliation, employment ties, etc. in the U.S. during their departure? What was the intention of the applicant at the time they departed?

Our Services

With so much on the line and so many variables to play in the N-400 decision making process, prospective applicants may find the counsel of an experience immigration lawyer to be not just helpful but necessary. In this regard, a call to Richard Hanus of the Law Offices of Richard Hanus not only will enhance your chances of success with the naturalization process but also guard you from taking a step that could negatively impact your immigration status.